Maxine
Hong Kingston is a first-generation Chinese immigrant who wrote a noteworthy memoir/novel
called The Woman Warrior about her experiences
being raised in America by Chinese parents. The excerpt we read in class
reveals the intimate childhood memories that she experienced while growing up
surrounded by a vast amount of varying influences and pressures. Maxine expresses
the challenges of assimilating to her environment due to the struggle between
the clashes of the Chinese and American cultures at school and at home. I
relate to her experience since my parents immigrated to the United States 28
years ago, leaving me to be the first generation of my family to experience the
American dream. Her descriptions, although sprinkled with some over exaggeration,
still have deep roots in truth that coincides with most first-generation
children experiences, like my own.
Maxine shares the hardships that
come with balancing the cultural standards imposed by her parents and the
contrasting cultural and social norms enforced by the US. This aspect of
balancing two cultures holds true to many experiences that immigrants have
during their transition to a new country especially with the language barrier
that arises. In the book, Maxine describes the tedious and unforgiving occurrences that took place at her American school, and describes having an especially hard time speaking
in a confident voice during her American classes. She was not the only one who
experienced this, she says “…other Chinese girls did not talk either, so [she]
knew the silence had to do with being a Chinese girl,” (Woman Warrior) showing
that there is an overarching struggle for most immigrants to let go of their
Chinese language and adapt to the English language that seems impossible to
comprehend. Maxine eloquently portrays the struggle of having two different
languages being interchangeably used in her life with both Chinese and English
school, which is often seen in many immigrant households. I had to go to both
English and Polish school, and mixing these two languages proved to negatively
impact my learning experience because I would find myself being penalized for writing
in the wrong language. I agree with Maxine’s representation of the hardships of
balancing two different cultures because the overload of cultural influences
proves to be merciless.
There are some aspects of the book
that are a bit embellished for the purpose of creating a more interesting and
eventful novel, yet the root of the exaggeration is applicable. For example,
the mother’s request for Maxine to get revenge on the mistake of the drugstore
delivery boy by demanding free reparation candy seems to be harsher and more out
of perspective than anything my culturally confused parents would force me to
do. This extravagant part of the story was included to create a deeper sympathy
for Maxine and isolate the mother completely into the realm of ignorance in
terms of the social workings of her new country. There is truth beneath the inflated
story because there is a very large gap in comprehension in regards to
immigrant parents when immersed in the different ways of American people. They
try to grasp onto their old culture, which creates a turmoil for the children
because they must battle between the two major influences of their lives, home
life and school life. When hearing the demands of her mother, Maxine is
instantly mortified and resents her mother for believing that the boy had
cursed their household and sending her to humiliate herself in the store since
this task reflects the noticeable divide between American and Chinese cultures
and perceptions of curses. Similarly, my parents have made me feel embarrassed about
their misunderstanding of American culture, for example their rude remarks and
confusion about Santa Claus since in the Polish Culture Angels bring presents Christmas
Eve. Yet they never made me do things that went against the obvious American
processes like demanding free candy but they definitely questioned aspects of
the foundation of American culture. This coincides with The Woman Warrior perception of parents being out of the cultural
loop but Maxine portrays her mother in a more negative and embellished manner
than I believe is true for all immigrants.
The similarities between Maxine’s
experiences and my own growing up with foreign parents make me sympathize with
her struggles. Her experiences lead the reader to believe that she is stuck in
the middle of the two cultures, being constantly harassed by her mother to
uphold their Chinese traditions and customs while getting forced in school to
mold to the American idea of an exemplarity citizen. Times have changed since
her novel was released yet most first or second generation children get stuck
between two cultures. If I were the author, I would add more content about how truly
lucky immigrants are to be able to call two places home. Having these
experiences make you grow as a person, giving you a blend of traditions and a
unique perspective on opportunity. If my parents never moved to America, I
would never have the chance to study animal science at UC Davis and pursue my
passion of becoming an equine veterinarian and I want to thank them for that
opportunity every day. I believe that Maxine would not have developed into the
writer she is today without the contrasting cultures she experienced as an
immigrant child, which she should value by including it in her work.
I like this post because it gives me insight into what it is like to be a first generation American. Your observation regarding the exaggeration of her stories is very interesting and I agree that the root of the exaggeration is applicable. It is cool to me that you added that you think immigrants are lucky to have two homes because I feel like that is not a common feeling. Also, are you Polish? My great grandparents immigrated to America from Poland at the start of WWII.
ReplyDeleteI really like your post and how it describes the first generation experience. You describe the struggles that Maxine Hong Kingston had and relate them to your own experiences very well but also argue the extent of the immigrant experience. I also agree and have had similar experiences with my immigrant parents how they try to impose some of their cultural traditions on me but never so much as actively forcing them on me. I also like how you described Maxine Hong Kingston as being divided between her Chinese culture and her American culture. I think this idea is very relevant for first generation people growing up because they sometimes seem lost about their identity. Good work!
ReplyDelete